The Science of Belonging: Why Students Thrive When They Feel Valued
DR. CHRISTOPHER S. CULVERThe simple yet profound act of feeling valued and connected within a community has a ripple effect on students' academic, social, and emotional well-being. Research consistently highlights that a sense of belonging is not just a "nice-to-have" aspect of school culture; it is a critical factor that can determine a student's success or struggle. Yet, 50% of adolescents feel alone and 1 in 10 students report that they do not have friends (Haight, 2021; Harding, 2019). The evidence of belonging supports improved academic and social outcomes, and strategies to foster belonging in schools.
Belonging is a fundamental human need. Psychologist Abraham Maslow positioned it as a core component of his hierarchy of needs, nestled between physiological and safety needs and the higher aspirations of esteem and self-actualization. For students, belonging means feeling accepted, supported, and valued by their peers, teachers, and the broader school community. This is a basic human need – we are all naturally wired to want to belong.
A 2018 study published in Educational Psychology found that students with a strong sense of belonging are more likely to engage in learning, participate in class, and develop positive relationships with their teachers. Conversely, a lack of belonging can lead to feelings of isolation, decreased motivation, and a higher risk of dropping out. These findings emphasize that belonging is not an abstract ideal but a measurable and impactful element of education.
When students feel they belong, their academic performance often improves. According to a meta-analysis published in Review of Educational Research (2020), students with a strong sense of belonging demonstrated higher grades, better attendance, and improved persistence in challenging tasks compared to their peers who felt disconnected.
The mechanisms behind this relationship are multifaceted:
Increased Motivation: Belonging fosters intrinsic motivation. Students are more likely to engage with learning materials and persist through difficulties when they feel supported by their peers and teachers.
Reduced Anxiety: With anxiety as the number one issue facing today’s generation, a sense of belonging alleviates the stress and anxiety that often accompany academic challenges. When students feel safe and valued, they can focus on learning rather than worrying about rejection or exclusion.
Enhanced Self-Efficacy: Feeling part of a community boosts students' confidence in their abilities. This belief in their capacity to succeed directly impacts their willingness to take risks and explore new ideas.
Students who feel connected to their school community are more likely to develop healthy relationships, demonstrate empathy, and exhibit prosocial behaviors. This sense of connection helps reduce bullying and conflict while fostering a culture of mutual respect and collaboration.
The opposite is also true. A lack of belonging often correlates with negative social outcomes such as loneliness, isolation, and antisocial behavior. A 2021 report by The Journal of Adolescence revealed that students who felt excluded or marginalized were at a higher risk of experiencing depression and engaging in risky behaviors. This underscores the importance of creating inclusive school environments where every student feels valued.
Several landmark studies provide compelling evidence of the importance of belonging in schools:
Goodenow and Grady (1993): This foundational study highlighted that school belonging is a stronger predictor of academic motivation and performance than socioeconomic status or prior achievement.
Yeager et al. (2019): Research on "belonging interventions" demonstrated that small, strategic efforts—such as affirming that feelings of uncertainty are normal and temporary—can significantly improve students' sense of belonging and long-term academic success.
Walton and Cohen (2007): This study found that even brief social-belonging interventions reduced the achievement gap for underrepresented students, demonstrating that targeted efforts to foster belonging can have lasting impacts.
Creating a culture of belonging requires intentional efforts at every level of a school community. Below are some evidence-based strategies to help students feel valued and connected:
Build Strong Relationships:
Teachers can prioritize getting to know their students as individuals. Simple practices such as greeting students by name, showing genuine interest in their lives, and maintaining open lines of communication can make a significant difference. Such interactions increase student engagement by 33%!
Peer mentorship programs can help students form supportive relationships with their classmates.
Cultivate Inclusive Environments:
Create classroom spaces that celebrate diversity and encourage every voice to be heard. Displaying culturally responsive materials and facilitating discussions about inclusion can help students feel seen and valued. This approach increases motivation and engagement by 55%!
Establish clear anti-bullying policies and actively address instances of exclusion or discrimination.
Provide Opportunities for Contribution:
Encourage students to take on leadership roles in the classroom or school community. Giving them opportunities to contribute fosters a sense of purpose and belonging. 90% of today’s learners want opportunities for collaboration.
Service-learning projects can help students connect with their communities and see the value of their contributions.
Incorporate SEL Programs:
Social-emotional learning (SEL) programs that emphasize self-awareness, relationship skills, and empathy can enhance students' sense of belonging. 50% of students do not have a positive relationship with their teachers; create the space for all students to thrive!
Activities such as collaborative group work and peer discussions can strengthen interpersonal connections.
Address Belonging Proactively:
Regularly assess students’ sense of belonging through surveys or discussions. Use this data to identify gaps and implement targeted interventions. 60% of today’s learners want to regularly engage in reflective conversations with their teachers and leaders.
Normalize conversations about belonging and emotional well-being, letting students know that their feelings matter.
The science of belonging is clear: when students feel valued, supported, and connected, they thrive. Belonging positively impacts academic achievement, social development, and emotional resilience. In a world where many young people face isolation and disconnection, fostering belonging is more critical than ever.
Treat others the way you want to be treated and may they remember you for your kindness. This work not only improves individual outcomes but also strengthens the fabric of the school community, paving the way for a brighter, more inclusive future for all learners.
Interested in being a future guest blogger? Reach out today! (Click here) We’d love to have you as part of “The Kind Voice!”
Are you receiving our weekly e-newsletter full of motivation, encouragement, and positivity? Subscribe today!
Want to be intentional with connecting with Gen Z/Alpha? Check out the 11 step guide FREE here! Or check out all of the free resources here!
Looking for Gen Z/Gen Alpha workshops? Keynote speaker? Read the testimonials from others’ experiences. Watch short clips from a most recent keynote! Would love to help you and your team; reach out today!